September 2023 Early Retirement Update

Hello and welcome back to another monthly update from Root of Good. We started last month with heavy bouts of consumerism, spending money like crazy on a new used car and half a dozen plumbing upgrades. By month’s end, we wrapped up the September projects and purchases and enjoyed more time relaxing in this beautiful fall weather we have right now.

In travel news, we officially have the bookends to our summer 2024 trip in place. We fly into Krakow, Poland in June for a nine week vacation that will take us from the mountains in the south of Poland to the Baltic Sea in the north. Our plans are wide open right now, and we may rebook the plane tickets depending on how our travel itinerary shapes up. 

On to our financial progress. September was mostly negative for our finances. Our net worth dropped by $79,000 to end September at $2,705,000. Our income totaled an impressive $8,498, while our spending was shockingly high at $12,714 for the month of September. 

Let’s jump into the details from last month.



Investment income totaled $5,025 in September. Our equity index funds and ETFs pay dividends quarterly at the end of March, June, September, and December. As a result, we had a larger than normal amount of investment income last month. Here’s more on our dividend investments.

Blog income totaled $547 for the month. This is the “new normal” for blog income since I only post on here about once per month. 

My early retirement lifestyle consulting income (“consulting”) was $350 in September. This represents two hours of consulting work. 

Tradeline sales income totaled $0 in September. Another slow month for tradeline sales. I ramped up my tradeline sales in 2020 and discussed it in a bit more detail in my October 2020 monthly post and in my July 2021 monthly post

For September, my “deposit income” totaled $50. This income came from cash back and incentive bonuses from the and online shopping portals (some of which was earned from you readers signing up through these links). 

If you sign up for Rakuten through this link and make a qualifying $25 purchase through Rakuten, you’ll get a $10 sign up bonus

Youtube income was $0 in September. Youtube only pays out when you hit $100 in accumulated revenue. Recently, my Youtube earnings have been just under $100 per month on average, so I only get paid every other month. 

Here is the Youtube channel for the curious. It’s random travel videos, birds, kids, and a couple of DIY videos. There are only a few main videos that bring in most of the traffic (and revenue!).

The final (and largest!) piece of income came from bank and credit card bonuses. I received a total of $2,525 worth of bonuses during September. The bulk of the bonus income came from a Wells Fargo promotion. We received $2,500 for transferring a quarter of a million dollars worth of ETFs into Mrs. Root of Good’s new IRA at Wells Fargo for a few months. I got the same bonus in my own account last month as well. In early October, I transferred these ETFs out of Wells Fargo and back to Citibank where we’ll get another $2,000 bonus in about six months.



If you’re interested in tracking your income and expenses like I do, then check out Empower Personal Dashboard, formerly known as Personal Capital (it’s free!). All of our savings and spending accounts (including checking, money market, and five credit cards) are all linked and updated in real time through Empower Personal Dashboard. We have accounts all over the place, and Empower Personal Dashboard makes it really easy to check on everything at one time.

Empower Personal Dashboard is also a solid tool for investment management. Keeping track of our entire investment portfolio takes two clicks. If you haven’t signed up for the free Empower Personal Dashboard service, check it out today (review here).

Tracking spending was one of the critical steps I took that allowed me to retire at 33. And it’s now easier than ever with Empower Personal Dashboard.




Now let’s take a look at September expenses:

In total, we spent $12,714 during September which is almost $10,000 more than our regularly budgeted $3,333 per month (or $40,000 per year). Automotive and groceries were the two highest categories of spending in September. 


Detailed breakdown of spending:


Automotive – $9,551:

We bought a new (used) car!! In very early September we purchased a 2017 Hyundai Accent SE hatchback with 99,000 miles on it for just under $9,200 including all fees, taxes, and registration. After a month of ownership, we haven’t discovered any nasty surprises so I think it’s going to work out well for us. 


Our new 2017 Hyundai Accent. I like it a lot so far. Nice little car to get around town in. The hatchback with folding rear seats could haul a lot of stuff if we ever get rid of the minivan.


So far we have only needed both cars simultaneously in a few instances during the past month. From a strictly financial optimization perspective, it would probably have been cheaper to take Uber in those circumstances. However it’s nice to be able to jump in a car and go whenever we want instead of waiting for an Uber to (maybe) show up. In the new year, we’ll have a child commuting to college and attending more in-person classes, so we couldn’t avoid buying a second car for much longer in any event. 

As all of you know, the costs of a car start with the purchase price. On top of that are maintenance costs, taxes, insurance, and gas. During September, I brought the car to our mechanic to swap out the spark plugs for $318 since it appears this service was slightly overdue based on the mileage of the vehicle. I also spent $35 for new engine and cabin air filters plus three new windshield wiper blades. It appears the used car dealer we purchased from didn’t do very much to maintain or improve the car but at least we paid well under blue book value. 


Groceries – $910:

We spent the whole month of September at home in Raleigh so $910 reflects a whole month of groceries. This is much higher than our spending before inflation picked up in 2021, but probably reflects the “new normal”. It seems like the rapid weekly or monthly grocery price hikes disappeared from my local stores’ shelves a while ago.


Fish curry soup – better than what you get at restaurants!


Home Maintenance – $749:

We tackled a long list of plumbing upgrades and repairs during September:

  • New dishwasher installation
  • repair kitchen sink drain pipe leak
  • 2x bathroom sink faucet and drain replacement with a full drain/p-trap rebuild on one of the sinks
  • replaced outdoor hose faucet
  • complete toilet rebuild due to leaking tank seal

Our long-time plumber charged us $749 for all the labor and materials (except the 2 Delta bathroom faucets I bought from Amazon for $50 using gift cards last month). 

I don’t know if $749 is a little or a lot for these plumbing services but this plumber was always fair to us in the past. However after this latest experience, I will be finding a new plumber.

He was difficult to get in touch with, he didn’t show up when he was supposed to on several occasions, and he never returned to take care of an installation problem with the outside faucet (I fixed it myself).

Ah, the joys of homeownership! I did some quick math to convince myself that owning is still better than renting. We’re getting about a 5% return per year from getting “free” rent from our house (net of expenses like taxes, insurance, and maintenance). Plus our house has roughly tripled in value over the last 2 decades since we bought it (annualized 5.8% return). Let’s assume in the future we average 4% per year gains and just barely beat inflation.

That’s a respectable 5% + 4% = 9% total return from our housing investment and it’s all tax free! As an added bonus, we have nearly infinite autonomy over our little third of an acre patch of land in Raleigh. No landlord can make us do anything! 


It’s nice to know we own this little slice of nature and won’t have to move if we don’t want to. 


Travel – $511:

The biggest travel expense for September was $370 in taxes and fees for our four round trip tickets to Poland for the summer of 2024. We also spent 30k American Aadvantage miles and 44k United miles for each round trip ticket. The cash price for these tickets are about $1,800 per round trip ticket. We saved about $6,800 by using airline miles plus a little cash to cover the taxes. 

Next summer in June, we plan on flying into Krakow where we’ll spend a week or two exploring the city and surrounding area. Then book a rental car and visit the mountainous countryside for a few weeks. Eventually we will pass through Wroclaw and make our way north to Gdansk where we fly home in mid-August. Most lodging and rental cars will be covered by points and miles of various sorts including many thousands of dollars worth of Airbnb gift cards I got for free last year from cashing out my Chase Ultimate Reward points.

Other travel spending for September includes $135 for our son’s renewal passport. And $6 for a convenience fee on our North Carolina quarterly estimated tax payment. I count convenience fees as travel expenses because we end up getting lots of free travel from using our credit cards as much as possible.


Get free travel like us

If you are interested in getting free travel from your credit card like I do, consider the Chase Ink Unlimited or Chase Ink Cash business cards (my referral link). Right now, for a limited time, the Chase Ink business cards offer an eye-popping 90,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points that can be redeemed instantly for $900 in cash. Mrs. Root of Good just picked up a new Chase Ink Cash card during March, and I just got my new Ink card this week. The bonuses keep on rolling in the door!

I am guessing the 90,000 point sign up bonus will only last for a few more weeks, so sign up now if you want the higher bonus amount. 

Chase is pretty liberal when it comes to “what is a business”. If you sell stuff on eBay or Craigslist or do some odd jobs occasionally then you have a business and could get a credit card as a “sole proprietor”. 

I use the 90,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points by transferring them to my Chase Sapphire Reserve card (also offering a 60,000 point sign up bonus right now). With the Sapphire Reserve card, I can get 1.5x the points value by booking cruises, flights, hotels, or rental cars through their travel portal. Or 1.25x value by reimbursing myself for groceries. That turns the 90,000 points into $1,350 of free travel or $1,125 of free groceries. Or I can transfer those Ultimate rewards points to over a dozen travel partners’ airline/hotel programs like United, Southwest, or Hyatt. I am about to book a $350 per night hotel in Florida for 9,000 Hyatt/Ultimate Reward points, for example.


Utilities – $362:

We spent $114 on our water/sewer/trash bill. 

The natural gas bill, which provides heating and hot water, totaled $18 for last month. 

The electricity bill totaled $231 in September. It was a hot summer and we used the air conditioning a lot. For the past couple of weeks we didn’t need AC so our upcoming electric bills should be fairly moderate. I also discovered that our electricity rates have crept up over the past few years from 10 cents per kilowatt hour to ~13 cents per kWh. In the past, a $200 summer electricity bill was a lot. Now that’s the “new normal” and I expect monthly bills over $250 in the future during peak summertime usage.


Taxes – $300:

$300 for quarterly estimated income taxes for the state of North Carolina. 


General Merchandise – $141:

Random items from Walmart including a lot of bird food and deer food. 


This group of 2 bucks and 2 does has been visiting for many months.


The mama deer with her two babies just started showing up recently.


Gas – $84:

A tank of gas for the minivan ($52) and a tank of gas for the new Hyundai Accent ($32). The new car is more fuel efficient so we should spend a little less on gas in the future. 


Charitable Giving – $52:

We donated $52 to our nephew’s school fundraiser. I wasn’t sure whether to call this a gift or charity. 


Healthcare/Medical/Dental – $47:

Our current 2023 health insurance costs $18 per month, thanks to very generous Affordable Care Act subsidies that we receive due to our low ~$45,000 per year Adjusted Gross Income. 

Our 2023 dental insurance plans cost a total of $29 in premiums per month. 

I chose a very basic plan for $9 per month for me that covers most preventive care but no fillings. Mrs. Root of Good has a different set of dental needs than I do so we kept the more comprehensive $20 per month plan for her (same as 2022’s plan).

By buying insurance, we should save a couple hundred dollars on my dental care. For Mrs. Root of Good, we will still save a few dollars compared to paying cash for the preventive dentist visits throughout the year.


This hawk caught a cardinal in our back yard. These birdies look like friends here but it did not end well for the cardinal.


Education – $10:

A high school transcript request fee for the kids’ community college. The dysfunctional college bureaucracy continues to surprise us by consistently losing previously submitted transcripts. 


Cable/Satellite/Internet – $0:

We generally pay $18 per month for a local reduced rate package due to having a lower income and having kids. 30 mbit/s download, 4 mbit/s upload. Right now the cost of the internet service is temporarily reduced to $0 due to the “Affordable Connectivity Program”. 



Year to Date Spending – 2023



We spent $30,243 during the first nine months of 2023. This annual spending is just a couple hundred dollars more than the $30,000 we budgeted for nine months of spending in our $40,000 annual early retirement budget.

As I guessed last month, our new car purchase didn’t throw our annual spending off by very much. We’re still within one percent of where we should be at this time of year. What expert budgeting and forecasting! 

I don’t think we have a lot of other big spending for the remainder of 2023. Hopefully we can book some fall travel for Mrs. Root of Good and I. We just got our renewal passports back this week, so we can finally get out of town once we find somewhere to go.

In reality, much of this travel will be free for us since we’ll be paying with points, miles, and free airbnb credit for flights, lodging, and any cruise fares.


Monthly Expense Summary for 2023:


Summary of annual spending from all ten years of early retirement:


Perfect weather means more sitting on the back porch watching the birds and propping my feet up


Net Worth: $2,705,000 (-$79,000)

Our net worth dropped by $79,000 to end September at $2,705,000. Another steep decline that reflects about two years of our annual budget disappearing in a short span of time. 

Am I worried yet?

Short answer: “no”.

Longer answer: these types of monthly declines are normal fluctuations in the stock market that happen from time to time. Short term, we suffer from the volatility.

Perhaps “suffer” is a strong word because I really don’t care. I only check the net worth stats at month-end to pull together these monthly updates. I have several months of cash in my checking account and get routine cash injections from various sources such as dividends, bank/credit card sign up bonuses and blog/tradeline/consulting income. 

Long term, the stock market goes up when the underlying fundamentals improve. I’m patient and don’t need to sell hardly any investments on a month to month basis to survive. Eventually the stock market will return to boomtimes and we’ll all be wealthier as a result. 



For the curious, our net worth reported above includes our home value (which is fully paid off). However, please note that I don’t consider my home value as part of my portfolio for “4% rule” calculation purposes. I realize folks ask me about that every month so I just wanted to state that here for clarity.


The weather cooled off enough to get the lakeside campfires going again


Life update

The end of August and the beginning of September was kind of a grind. It’s always busy when we get back from our two month summer vacations, but this fall was particularly rough. We kicked the new car search into gear and after searching and searching, we found something we liked.  Then we had to clean the car a bit, do some research/troubleshooting, and complete a few deferred maintenance tasks on it.

In parallel to the car acquisition, I spent a good bit of time researching and sourcing plumbing parts and services and then overseeing our sketchy non-responsive plumber. 

Are we ruling our things or are our things ruling us? 

By the end of last month, things slowed down for us. Now that everything is done, we get to relax. I am definitely thankful I didn’t have to juggle all these different tasks while also working full time. That wouldn’t be fun at all! 

Okay folks, that’s it for me this month. See you next time!


Have you ever had to deal with a difficult contractor? What did you do in the end?


Want to get the latest posts from Root of Good? Make sure to subscribe on Facebook, Twitter, or by email (in the box at the top of the page) or RSS feed reader.

Root of Good Recommends:
  • Personal Capital* - It's the best FREE way to track your spending, income, and entire investment portfolio all in one place. Did I mention it's FREE?
  • Interactive Brokers $1,000 bonus* - Get a $1,000 bonus when you transfer $100,000 to Interactive Brokers zero fee brokerage account. For transfers under $100,000 get 1% bonus on whatever you transfer
  • $750+ bonus with a new business credit card from Chase* - We score $10,000 worth of free travel every year from credit card sign up bonuses. Get your free travel, too.
  • Use a shopping portal like Ebates* and save more on everything you buy online. Get a $10 bonus* when you sign up now.
  • Google Fi* - Use the link and save $20 on unlimited calls and texts for US cell service plus 200+ countries of free international coverage. Only $20 per month plus $10 per GB data.
* Affiliate links. If you click on a link and do business with these companies, we may earn a small commission.


  1. Since you have ETF and index funds you may want to take a look at the book promoted on this page (I am not the author and I am not related and will not be compensated, etc, etc, except maybe get a second opinion as I started reading it and it makes a lot of sense to me…)
    It is about selling covered calls (and maybe cash-secured puts) on the investments you already have. I am doing something similar with the individual stocks I have.

  2. Those plumbing repairs are dirt cheap. Pay a few bucks more to get someone reliable and your still way within reason.

    It’s nearly impossible to quantify the mental/emotional benefits of homeownership vs renting. Even if the math isn’t always favorable, not having someone pull the rug out from under you for no reason with no notice is priceless. Landlords can make you dance like a marionette.

    Watch the deer – they can get ornery during rutting season.

    1. That’s true about stability. I know another FIRE couple that were happily renting for several years, and right before the next year’s renewal their landlord gave them a 30 day notice to vacate. So it was a scramble to find temp housing while they looked to buy a place. And then they had to move twice as a result.

  3. It amazed me how many points you get with your low spending and that the companies have no strict rules for paying out bonuses (e.g. you have to stay with them for 5-10 years etc.). I guess the US is a different market than what I’m used to know.

    1. I have heard from international folks that the freebies and bonuses in the USA are comparatively ridiculous. There aren’t a lot of rules about keeping the cards long term. Amazon might be the most strict by allowing new card bonuses every ~7 years and they will blacklist you if you cancel in <12 months. Some other companies like Chase and Citi have implemented 24 or 48 month waiting periods to get another bonus on the same card, so that limits us to a certain extent.

  4. 1. Make sure you keep an eye on the timing belt. Sounds like it may be due for a replacement. It’s an extreme important item many tend to overlook.

    2. We’ve been considering the 2024 Chevy Trax. Brand new for “only” $24,000. Not bad.

    3. Why didn’t you do the plumbing repairs yourself?

    1. Timing chain on the new car, so fortunately not a big expense coming up there. The spark plugs were the only “major” repair at this mileage so it wasn’t too expensive. I am maybe due for some fluid changes but not really sure when they were completed last.

      Re the Trax – not a bad price but I think I was reading that engine type has had some reliability problems.

      Plumbing – I could have done some of the plumbing myself (like the dishwasher install and toilet repair) but wanted to outsource all of it as an experiment. I’d probably do the dishwasher install and toilet myself next time. And the other stuff was a little beyond my skill level, so I decided to lump all the jobs together to hopefully score a better price.

  5. Congratulations on buying a new to you Hyundai. If the car key is a simple steel key, your car may not have an immobilizer and you may want to either invest in a steering lock or getting an immobilizer put in.

    It seems that 2015-2019 Kia and Hyundai are popular with car thieves because of this. More details at

    Why do I know this? Because somebody stole a Hyundai Accent and crashed it into my backyard fence on Monday night.

  6. Completing minimum spend requirements for credit card welcome bonuses is more challenging when monthly spending is low.

    Do you do manufactured spending?

    1. Not too much. Just put everything on my card that’s possible. Like paying property and income taxes on the card. And I pay for my parents’ home insurance and property taxes on my card too (and get reimbursed).

      1. I’m so impressed by your modest spending.

        And you’ve now inspired me to read more about paying taxes with credit cards.

  7. Thanks for the updates. I’ve read them all for many years. Do you do a Roth Ladder? What drives your income tax?

    1. Yes, we do the Roth Conversions most years. Our AGI is around 45,000 most years which means we don’t owe any federal income taxes after all the credits and deductions. But we do owe a small amount of state income taxes however.

  8. Love the updates! Do you have a link where we can see the promo that Wells Fargo had to get the $2500 or the $2,000 from Citi? Was this a brokerage account transfer? Would I be able to transfer a traditional IRA or a SEP IRA with over 250k in it to get the same deals? Thanks.

    1. I believe IRAs or taxable brokerage accounts all work for Citi and Wells Fargo. Some places won’t give the bonus for IRAs so watch out.

      Current links: Wells Fargo (a Doctor of Credit article about the promo)

      Citi bonus (a Doctor of Credit article about the promo)

    1. There are still plenty of bank bonuses to be had, but some of them are not worth it due to low interest rates on said accounts and long holding times for large amounts. What Justin did was more of a brokerage bonus though.

  9. “Ah, the joys of homeownership! I did some quick math to convince myself that owning is still better than renting. We’re getting about a 5% return per year from getting “free” rent from our house (net of expenses like taxes, insurance, and maintenance). Plus our house has roughly tripled in value over the last 2 decades since we bought it (annualized 5.8% return). Let’s assume in the future we average 4% per year gains and just barely beat inflation.”

    Justin, would you consider writing a post expanding on this thought further? I am a current renter who sold a few years ago, trying to think properly about housing and would love to hear in more detail how you thought this through and arrived at your returns numbers – especially the return on “free” rent piece.

    Thanks for considering

  10. Justin – Glad you heading to Poland. I was there last year. We have found the country to be very very safe but prices were higher than expected. Be careful when entering and extiothr cities or small towns. There are many times cops there to give you a speeding ticket – Make sure to get International Driver’s License as they require that FOR US drivers.

    1. Thanks for the tip on the Intl Driver’s License. I read conflicting reports about it, but probably worth getting it to avoid issues with police or rental car agencies.

      I’ve seen the crazy inflation in Poland on restaurant menus. Sometimes 25-50% over the past couple of years.

      1. One word of advice. Avoid a “budget” car rental by the name of Green Power. They’re complete scammers. Days after we returned our rental they hit our credit card for $200. When I tried to call the company I learned that the number I had was no longer valid. Turns out the phone number only worked while we had the car. I later researched online and learned they’re a scam. British tv has even done exposés on them. I learned from this to pay a bit more and stick with the big well known rental companies. But, I was trying to save a Buck.

        You’re going to love Poland, it’s a beautiful country with wonderful people.

        1. That’s scary, and luckily I’ve avoided the rental car scams. It seems like most of the rental car companies have negative reviews like that, and I don’t know what to do other than document the car condition ahead of time and hope that they don’t scam me. We did have a scammy rental car from Hungary that felt like they were trying to rip me off at various points of the rental, but I stuck to my guns and didn’t pay them anything extra, and demanded that they honor my originally agreed arrangement. Always a risk though.

  11. How tough was it to get to those spark plugs? That’s seems pretty high but I know some cars have them placed in a less than ideal position, and you have to remove a bunch of “stuff” to get to them.

    And I agree with Dave S – the plumbing tasks sound like your could have done them yourself based upon the prior work you have done. None were that difficult but if you just wanted to save the time, understandable.

    1. These spark plugs were about as easy as any to access. I probably could have done it myself but just couldn’t be bothered 🙂 I figure $100 or a bit more for the plugs and the cables (it’s the 100k miles fancy platinum iridium whatever plugs so they are a bit $$$$$). Other $200 is labor. Inflation means everything costs more and I am sure this was a $200 job 3-4 yrs ago. We did have to pay over $600 for spark plugs in our minivan because they were deep behind half the stuff underneath the hood so I think they charged 3-4 hours of shop time to swap out those plugs. And that was 2017-ish, so I have to guess it would cost $800-900 today for the same service. Fortunately it’s a 120k mile change interval on those plugs so the van will be in the junkyard by the time that rolls around again.

  12. Hey, long time reader, always enjoy your updates! Would you mind sharing details on y’all’s dental plan and satisfaction level? I’m retiring at the end of the month, we get to keep our health plan, but not the dental, so I’m in the market! Thank you!

    1. Sure – we got them both from the ACA healthcare dot gov exchange. One is Dominion Dental and the other is Truassure. I just make sure the plan covers what we need and has our dentist in network. So far we’ve been happy with the insurance. It’s not perfect and doesn’t cover 100% of the costs but we get back at least what we pay for insurance through free or discounted routine services and the occasional filling or other 1 time procedures.

  13. Wow a whole summer in poland next year will be amazing. Are you going to any neighboring countries?
    Is the loose plan to spend a week in each city or a few weeks in the big ones like Krakow?

  14. Empower Personal Dashboard is behaving strangely lately. My dividends aren’t being counted as income even though the option is unchecked in settings. Cashflow is out of wack….Empower really screwed up what personal capital had the best

  15. Justin, Thank you for the info with regards to the Wells Fargo $2500 bonus.
    I was able to take advantage of the offer, however the Citi bank offer is $1000 for IRA accounts (200K). just got off the phone with Citi. There is a $200 subscription offer,
    Costco, Amazon Prime, HULU and a few other merchants are participating. Citi classifies these kind of accounts (200K and over) as citigold.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.